Friday, September 30, 2022

Judge Overrules Special Master

 Judge Aileen M. Cannon has further demonstrated her lack of fitness to serve on the federal bench. First, she ruled that a special master must be appointed to review the documents seized at former president Donald Trumps's Mara Lago estate and stayed the Justice Department's investigation of their removal and retention, a decision that has been roundly criticized in legal circles and partially reversed by an appellate court. Judge Cannon appointed as special master Judge Raymond Dearie, the candidate recommended by Mr. Trump's lawyers.

When it became apparent that Judge Dearie, a senior federal district judge, was acting decisively and with dispatch, disappointing the Trump legal team's expectations and strategy for delay and obfuscation, Judge Cannon intervened to tether Judge Dearie and slow him down. By patently putting her thumb on the scales of justice, to advantage the man who appointed her, Judge Cannon is bringing disrepute to the federal judiciary and undermining the rule of law.
The Justice Department should consider appealing this latest travesty; failing that, Judge Dearie should consider issuing a noisy resignation as special master.

Monday, September 5, 2022

Republicans Eye a New Constitution

 


The American constitution, the world's oldest, is justly venerated as the touchstone of a democratic society. Together with certain of its amendments, it enshrines and protects many basic human rights and civil liberties. As a symbol, it remains a grand and inspiring work of political genius. As a working document, interpreted by an originalist Supreme Court, it is a straitjacket that impedes changes required by an evolving reality.
Oddly, the pressure to rewrite the constitution is coming from both the Left and the Right and many progressives and conservatives share a concern that a new constitution will wipe away the protection and advantages each side prizes. Recent legislative actions and inactions and decisions of the Supreme Court have made transparent the need for a major overhaul of our founding document. The dilemma posed is how to accomplish this without putting in jeopardy the bedrock principles of a democracy and risking the adoption of a document that is nationalistic, homophobic, gender-biased, religiously slanted and gun-centered.
The bottom line is that a new constitution must be adopted by a broad spectrum of the American people, not by a vote of states which may constitute a majority but represent less than a majority of the electorate. Indeed, the phenomenon of lightly populated states wielding disproportionate influence over national priorities is one of the defects of our electoral system that should be remedied by a new constitution.

Wednesday, August 10, 2022

Simmering Feud Peaks in Search of Trump's Home

 

The court-approved search of the estate used by former president Donald Trump as a home and backdrop for his political machinations, for documents belonging to the government and wrongfully taken by Mr. Trump has triggered a not unexpected backlash by his aroused base. Though the decision to conduct the search was striking it was perfectly lawful, consistent with actions taken by the Department of Justice in the past against other high ranking public officials who disregarded the law governing document handling and furthers the important principle that no one is above the law.While the search certainly has political implications and is fair game for criticism on that score by Trump allies, what is especially troubling is the irresponsible rhetoric of Republican public officials, who use false assertions and unwarranted assumptions to fan the dangerous anger erupting within that segment of Trump’s following that perpetrated the assault on the nation's capital. These undisguised calls for war are bound to move the violent fringe to act out in ways that will wreak havoc and further strain the rule of law already close to breaking.

Monday, July 11, 2022

Chief Justice Roberts Should Retire

 

Pamela Paul’s suggestion, that Chief Justice Roberts, by retiring, would help the Supreme Court move toward positions that more broadly reflect the opinions of most Americans, rather than those of an extremist faction, is naive and nonsensical. Granted his replacement by a liberal Chief would tip the ideological balance on the court a little to the left. But the remaining five Justices, constituting the ultra-conservative majority, would still be firmly entrenched and will continue their march toward dismantling the rule of law, protecting the rich and corporate citizenry, the ultra-religious and the gun-crazed segment of society. Only expanding the court or imposing fixed terms will prevent the current constitutional death spiral from continuing into the foreseeable future.

Monday, July 4, 2022

Police Say Unarmed Black Man in Traffic Stop Was Shot 60 Times

 This country has been afflicted by an epidemic of police shootings stemming from routine traffic stops. Many states and localities have responded by placing limits on the police practice of pursuing fleeing motorists. The sensible rule adopted in these jurisdictions is that pursuit should not be initiated if the risk of harm to the police or others outweighs the risk posed by failing to effect the stop. So, for example, a broken taillight does not warrant a high-speed chase that may result in traffic fatalities or the gunning down of the motorist.

Unfortunately, this sound restriction on police response has not been universally adopted or regularly adhered to. As a consequence, the nation continues to suffer a plethora of these tragic and unnecessary shootings.

Police Say Unarmed Black Man in Traffic Stop Was Shot 60 Times

 This country has been afflicted by an epidemic of police shootings stemming from routine traffic stops. Many states and localities have responded by placing limits on the police practice of pursuing fleeing motorists. The sensible rule adopted in these jurisdictions is that pursuit should not be initiated if the risk of harm to the police or others outweighs the risk posed by failing to effect the stop. So, for example, a broken taillight does not warrant a high-speed chase that may result in traffic fatalities or the gunning down of the motorist.

Unfortunately, this sound restriction on police response has not been universally adopted or regularly adhered to. As a consequence, the nation continues to suffer a plethora of these tragic and unnecessary shootings.

Saturday, July 2, 2022

The 14th Amendment and Fetal Rights

 


Erika Bachiochi's erudite-sounding defense of a ban on abortion, as the protection of a separate, vulnerable person dependent on the care of its host, fails to consider all the ramifications of unintended pregnancy. 
For one, pregnancy may be the result of rape, a brutal tactic often employed in war to dishearten and impair an enemy population. These pregnancies are war crimes akin to the random planting of landmines and the notion that a rape victim has some moral or legal obligation to nurture and complete the intended crime is simply unconscionable. 
The originalist argument, that the drafters of the 14th Amendment intended to protect unborn life, is equally flawed. Even if true, and that is disputable, the drafters were all 19th century men, hardly exemplars of those who would protect women's rights.